ABSTRACT Title of Thesis: TENDING Caitlin Reid, Master of Fine Arts, 2018 Thesis directed by: Professor Stanley Plumly, Department of English Tending is a poetry collection concerned with the mutability of landscapes, stories, and relationships. In a mix of free-verse sonnets, found language, and discovered forms, these narrative poems listen for the old songs and everyday birds that drift through urban and pastoral settings to flood the speaker with memory. TENDING by Caitlin Reid Thesis submitted to the Faculty of the Graduate School of the University of Maryland, College Park, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Fine Arts 2018 Advisory Committee: Professor Stanley Plumly, Chair Professor Joshua Weiner Professor Gerard Passannante © Copyright by Caitlin Reid 2018 Acknowledgements I’ve borrowed five titles that I’m aware of: “Almagest” from Ptolemy, “Casida of the Branches” from Federico Garcia Lorca, “Into the Dusk-Charged Air” from John Ashbery, “After Apple-Picking” from Robert Frost, and “Who do you wish was with us?” from Dylan Thomas. “Cathedral of Learning, after Orientation” borrows a line from Octavio Paz’s poem “Piedra de Sol” (“Sunstone”), translated by Eliot Weinberger. “Version Control” is a found poem from a Git white page on the subject. “Second Marriage” adapts language from a National Park Service Preservation Brief called Repointing Mortar Joints in Historic Masonry Buildings. ii Table of Contents Acknowledgements…………………………………………………………………...ii Table of Contents……………………………………………………………………..iii Skyfishing…………………………………………………………………………..…1 Self-Taught ................................................................................................................... 2 Almagest ....................................................................................................................... 3 Epithalamion ................................................................................................................. 4 Waiting Where We Can Go Home ............................................................................... 5 Like Rose Oil in Wooden Vials .................................................................................... 6 The Hell It Is…………………………………………………………………………..7 Sugarsnaps…………………………………………………………………………….9 Indelible.......................................................................................................................10 A Visiting Congregation..............................................................................................11 Casida of the Branches.................................................................................................12 Admittance...................................................................................................................13 Killdeer........................................................................................................................14 Anthem for My Brother...............................................................................................15 Into the Dusk-Charged Air...........................................................................................16 The Cathedral of Learning, after Orientation..............................................................18 Version Control............................................................................................................19 Proofreading.................................................................................................................20 From a Glacier Since Retreated...................................................................................21 Oliver Poem.................................................................................................................22 After Apple-Picking.....................................................................................................24 Street Sweeping...........................................................................................................25 Counting Poem............................................................................................................26 Bananas for Stu............................................................................................................27 Second Marriage..........................................................................................................28 Who do you wish was with us?...................................................................................29 Tumbling Run..............................................................................................................30 Kevlar and Calfskin.....................................................................................................31 Crayfish.......................................................................................................................32 Against Elegy..............................................................................................................33 Pruning........................................................................................................................34 Hillwater.....................................................................................................................35 Tending.......................................................................................................................40 iii Skyfishing We play a game to bring the bats. They have to be invited at dusk when we expect no more cars to cross our country road. We crouch to drag our fingers through the blue-stone gravel, count down for the jump, and scatter fists of stony bait that tempt them to us. As we watch for the rocks to pause between their rise and fall, for stillness, something tucks my chin to chest exactly as the hard rain rattles down. We lift our heads to light sucked up by silhouettes of pear trees piercing the horizon. Then bats arrive as slips of black flung about in dips and surges, as if by the will of another being on the ground with a control box and antenna. The bats hear our cast stones as gnats and mosquitoes because that’s what they want. We lie and they listen, as you are listening now. Sonar requires a specific kind of believing after you hurl your own call out to bounce around the different darks. 1 Self-Taught there’s a radial arm saw in our family my father gave my brother headed north looking for land with his lover and child I remember my great-grandfather Charlie balancing a pool cue on the two-and-a-half fingers making his left hand how winter came and he didn’t have shoes for school and a teacher gave him her old pair a kindness too big too pretty too essential to be squandered you can’t get back the things you needed when you had them the man who raised my father took the safety off to best cut teak candlesticks that burned the first time I tried candlelight a good case for precious metals better hand-me-downs what happened to his missing fingers I know without asking in our family you pick them up yourself 2 Almagest City starlight struggles through the thick grape arbor of a restaurant I can’t afford. I feel tired and late for something, as if elsewhere’s streetlights burn fresher bulbs. Looking up is the oldest human longing. I’m grateful for the alternative firmament of fruit, predictable spheres to reach for from a barstool with more than the naked eye. I’d like to locate enough stars to string together one familiar shape. On my father’s farm, a black velvet sky houses polished things. There, I could show you your star sign. Now a purple dark crowds the tea lights on my table and what might be stars, satellites, or mid-flight planes. Night doesn’t fall here. Dawn doesn’t break. Days fade, and nights arrive already faded. I’m unlearning everything as arbitrary as a constellation. No shapes, no stories to trap and trick the light, to cut and tumble the world into being more than it is. 3 Epithalamion There are songs that surprise by lasting like snow in the mountain’s lee, where a half-mile bluff shields the lowlands. Sing song kitty can’tcha ki-me-o On learning a nonsense song: by the chorus you’ll want another version to get under or behind the first fuddle in your ear. Sing song kitty can’tcha ki-me-o When language strikes out in two directions, stripped of meaning and double pressed, a second singer makes it clear. In Gaelic or sun-struck woods, He-mo hi-mo beetle bug jingle Me-he mi-ho pretty pennywinkle what you say twice is true. Ramp tom-a-doodle snake A-rang tangle rattlebug A-sing song kitty can’tcha ki-me-o When you want the words by heart, write them down. 4 Waiting Where We Can Go Home At the station where no train comes, I sit on the hard bench of expectation knowing precisely the position of my mother’s mind on the shelf in a house which no longer stands. They say it sounds like a train, the stillness after a storm. Trains in the trees when the water recedes. 5 Like Rose Oil in Wooden Vials The Bulgarians need a home for their goldfish. Peach and cherry blossoms snowball bloom with the apples on our Appalachian foothill, everything fragrant at once, delicate as the valley of the roses when they tip their glass bowl into our irrigation pond. They talk like birds to their fish and each other, then say in English, Give more chances than you get. They gift me Pushkin, ACDC, my first Led Zeppelin, some Zappa. I go back to Baltimore weekends for the market and report their fish are multiplying into new colors. I don’t tell them a blue heron’s feet mark the clay bank nightly. They’re both degreed and gone from Hopkins when a bigger pond is built below the first. Gravity feeds a few fish through the connector. They’re soon enormous. The same heron follows and now a kingfisher finds the rose-pink flashes in our cold black water. From the house I hear the thunk of fish-flesh on the headless drum of the overflow pipe. I’ve seen him swallow them whole. 6 The Hell It Is I don’t know how to pay respect or to whom. Honor is one fifth-grader being sweet to another, wanting to believe the real world is made of school rules and real life has better food. The boy with the reddest hair, pure red like an excuse to taunt and tease, he finds us before school as busses circle and spill children into the yard. Something about your book-bag makes him hate you. Lalala Bean, he sings. Then he calls me your little girlfriend, and I know you’ll show off your taekwondo while a crowd grows amused and mean. I like you best when you plead and repeat your schoolteacher parents, bright-hearted, reasoned. My sister took that stance against our mother once. The nurse told us, say It’s my body. No one can touch it without permission. Mom grabbed a silver hairbrush and replied, The hell it is. Childhood casts no light into the future. I could still learn to protect those I love instead of saving myself. I’ve glared at injustice most of my life, which is a strong way of watching and doing nothing. The redhead dies by fire when his helicopter clips a hill that isn’t much of a mountain. I’m stopped in traffic for his parade. 7 Mom strikes a bargain with Jesus and keeps it. My sister still says to say hi next I see you. I don’t admit you’re in jail again. They demolished that school this summer, carelessly, no attempt to dampen the deadly dust. Nothing breaks down as cleanly as it’s made. The dust gets deep in us all, and it stays. 8 Sugarsnaps No one can shit in the psych ward because the food is so bad, the same stuff delivered to the county jail. My mother’s mind improves but her guts distract her recovery. A cool spell grants sugarsnap vines long lives this year. They wrap their complicated shoots across the trellis near my car. I tear at the plants to fill a plastic grocery bag. It’s been a week. I drive a different highway than I did this morning for work. Crisp, sweet sugarsnaps will make my mother less crazy than the others. An attendant reaches under his desk to open three doors. I sign in and he sneers: Don’t come here with that. Shakes the bag. They’ll suffocate themselves, or you. Peapods stretch the bowl of my shirt in a country way of carrying. The empty bag gets flattened and locked in a drawer. I’m handed the sticky square of my name that I wear on my visiting body. 9 Indelible I think of you so rarely, I’ll have to look you up. But sometimes I see you in my son, in cities you’ve never lived in or haven’t lived in yet, if you’ve kept yourself alive. Please be alive. Don’t quit staggering across the street while I watch from my car with the windows up, wondering where you sleep these days. A day-drinker weaves through traffic against the light. I stop without honking. I’m less angry now. As I wait I notice a butterfly land on a soft new sidewalk and fold its wings in prayer. I should have pulled the ladder up after us. I should have put you in a room, door and windows shut. Don’t come home to me. Don’t knock and ask my husband to use the shower. Don’t show up in the rain. Here comes a man with a sign about the wet cement. Through its feet, the butterfly tastes something hardening on its tongue. I’m still in a red car stopped for you at a green light. I remember our initials in wood, then stone. 10 A Visiting Congregation Invasive bird, invasive branch. Heavy is the tree with city kids, their eyes bright as our yard’s starlings. The flockful kind. Youth groups bussed to the corner-store church line up this Sunday morning. You step through them all. Bubbles jump up your bourbon bottle’s neck like a level gone awry. “You judge you.” Wobbly in ankle-twisting boots, pregnant until tomorrow. In the practiced shade of the Tree of Heaven you lean against, a forty-foot weed grown too deep to kill, I pull at your arm to keep us moving. Invited bird on invited branch. Red light caught in the black of your undone braid. 11 Casida of the Branches King-bloom, king-bloom, half-brown by bud-break: the limb that knows itself in other seasons than lush, sudden spring. Who sets out rainwater bowls for the rented honeybees? When the mountain shields the sunset from the tiny fists of leaves, some branches speak, some listen. Funny how little of a first eager star we’ll ever see. We say we love the water when we mean where the light touches, where our bodies are held, a few inches (if any) more, where water laps the ground. I’m puzzled by the untouched edge of you a few months out of reach and by the honeybee’s need to drink. Buzzards swirl and turn, riding thermals. Black hands on a blue face, still-winged over the dark-milk pond, a sky that’s right twice a day. It’s the stopped clock we circle around. 12 Admittance Past the window lined with chicken wire, hot air warps people parking cars. Our side is overly air-conditioned and much smudged by hands. I have just tried to dress my mother for the first time. She will not help me wrap this thin cotton gown over her symptoms: scars from the heavy traffic of organs and infants across her belly, the blue ink marked on her legs and breasts by a stray pen. There is no time to wet my thumb and rub these things away before the nurses return to fend off the dark birds and burning tires alight in her eyes. 13 Killdeer In the spring I wake to the tractor disking the tomato field into good tilth. The combing metal pings high notes of quartz and purple shale like uncovered nibs on a music box. My father turns the tractor in half-circles, led by the wing-point of a grounded bird. Collared like a priest or a bowling pin, a killdeer shows no distinct mark of being male or female, something my father would disapprove of if it occurred to him. The bird’s parenthood is spelled out by the broken-wing display. The gesture looks sincere. The truth is a bird that hides its offspring out in the open seems too stupid to survive. The truth is a shorebird satisfied by a pond wastes its wings while its chicks blend with the bare, unremarked earth. My father dislikes surprises, startled by his own father’s heart gone quiet its thirty-ninth year. There’s a face he makes when the mower chokes over rabbits or turtles. He brakes for most critters he finds in time, before the harrow can claw across a body like a pastry cutter. The eggs must have come close to the McCormick’s tires as the killdeer took a running start, raised a wing, and called its own name. How do such traditions begin instead of birds that build a better home? Tractor to tail feathers, my father follows by the rules of a hunt he hands down to me: Believe the bird long enough to lead you both away, until it heals itself and flies. 14 Anthem for My Brother Back then we had the radio, jazz and justice coming in good by the time we hit the first state line, sun-up by the second. One lane turned to two and then six walls of traffic. Always a crash to crawl through. There was a sound in you that wanted out—the apical dominance of uncuttable hair—like the reach of Hendrix at Woodstock from the fuzzed speakers of the F150 with the spongy brakes. Something for the commuters in suits come to rest around us, you said. Patriotic. You turned it up too loud for talking, rolled down the glass, and pressed your heart as some stared. I’ll remember this the dawn you head all-the-way west with what you owned turtle-topped to your Pontiac, how bungee-corded together we were to our name: a box truck, bad brakes, the fruit heating up in back, a blue bank bag at your knee. All our father’s. What work was, what we had between us the years I mothered where none was needed. 15 Into the Dusk-Charged Air Before he dies, before the set begins, Billy Higgins sways to something. For almost sixty years, Buddy Rich and Max Roach have it out on a wobbly record. In Nashville, one-armed Rick Allen keeps up by the river. Terri Lyne Carrington an octopus in Baltimore. Philly Joe Jones, not to be swapped for Papa Jo, though they die days apart after swimming on the set. All the men who stole the sock cymbal from Ethel Minor. Pittsburgh, the Hill District at night, Roger Humphries putting some oeuf on it, Art Blakey’s Messengers. Elvin Jones always telling a good story with a punchline. Kenny Klook-a-mop Clark moving time from hi-hat to ride. Baby Dodds’s shimmy beat shifting six over four in his solos. Bill McKinney and his Cotton Pickers subbing Cuba Austin, who then lights up Gene Krupa. Kofi Ghanaba getting Tony Allen ready for Fela Kuti’s marathons. Rashied Ali gentle at the end of Coltrane. Dennis Chambers speeding past what Scofield has to say. Heels aching to see Vinnie Colaiuta with Herbie. Never a chance of Second Great Quintet Tony Williams, but “Million Dollar Legs” on cassette. Butch Trucks talking squash blossoms and Voltaire the day he goes. Lenny White with Chick in Return to Forever. Chico Hamilton with everyone. Chester Thompson after Zappa, Little Feat’s double set but no double pedals (what feet are for). Richie Hayward’s rock and shuffle before he passed. Richie Ramone at The Bayou in Georgetown. Jay Lane stomping swampflats for Claypool. Topper Headon before getting steady on heroin. Surviving his wife’s wound to his chest, Al Jackson Jr. takes five bullets later in his back. Perfect timing, Clyde Stubblefield and Jabo Starks pulling James Brown from the wings over and over. Omar Hakim fluttering around Bowie and Madonna. The other Knopfler brother. Jojo Mayer with Nina Simone singing paradiddle melodies. Stanton Moore and his marching drum tuned way, way, down… So what Neil Pert and Carter Beauford, sorry Ringo. Nothing like James Gadson in the pocket. Eh to Stewart Copeland; too many toys. 16 But goofy Keith Moon, that dynamite. Like Louis Hayes with Horace Silver and Cannonball. Citizen Tain with Michael Brecker before his death. Bonham’s Ludwigs in the basement. John Ware watching The Hawks when he was young. Levon at the helm. Insane Ginger Baker seated before his altars. Tito Puente’s papacy of sound. Steve Gadd giving all kinds of weather. 17 The Cathedral of Learning, after Orientation Cruel, that building, some doors gone to fluorescent lights and linoleum, key-stoned arches over lamp-lit wells of stairs down sudden others. Flights we ran up and counted wrong, testing transoms and tapping windows. Midnight-gentle. The summer your mother lived in a commune, you learned locks from someone who let you sit shoulder-close on southern porches, who kept you out of the rain. You brought two tools to college: a Leatherman and the light-grabbing flash of something I didn’t recognize the night we broke in the church for a belfry we never found. Thinking of thunder for cover through that first good storm, of ringing bells that weren’t there. After thirty-six stories, you can’t hide how quick the gate gives way. What happens when you try. I see you still on that rooftop with the lit grid of your life before you, leaning into lightning strikes, under balconies of rain. 18 Version Control The task of keeping consistent many versions organized by who held it last is run on your own changes. Revert, compare each point of failure of centralization (the question of saving what’s different) of backup for when you have the entire history of a place in one place and risk losing everything. 19 Proofreading I’m too afraid of permanence to tattoo or pierce my body, still apprehensive after urges long done, like pregnancies, one of them carried to term. What’s the language of love-child and bastard but yes and no to being who you’ve been. A new girl at work garbles copy for our agency. She has a kind of turned-up beauty that scares me. I’ve never seen a tattoo inside a mouth. She pulls down the tongue-side of her bottom lip, where a fish would be hooked. Instead, ink needled iridescent, the letters backwards like on an ambulance. Dirty South. I don’t know why she’s shown me. We’re both a bit unqualified for our lives. I’ve wanted my own mistakes gone un-made or penciled in. Know things I won’t. Tell them to me. 20 From a Glacier Since Retreated Ice bluer than snow and dirty as something pushed aside in a parking lot by a plow. I don’t need to see all the ice hoards while it inches along. Give me one photo or an avalanche. Waterfalls gone stony, shelves of ice and ice hung like sheet-rock, I am standing in a dry riverbed of cold I can feel in my metal fillings, in the steel fixed to my boots. I want to hear ice groan, twisted by underground rivers. My lips and fingers are purple. I’m alone on a glacier in the rain for a moment before the guide reappears. He’s annoyed he’ll have to take me back. I can’t breathe and he doesn’t want me to slow the others down. I’ve had this conversation with a man nine thousand miles away. Everything sounds farther in kilometers. The road signs say I’m traveling faster than I am as I head into Albert Town to touch the buttons of a payphone, snow on the Southern Alps pristine from this distance. 21 Oliver Poem Some things I remember differently, low-pile high-traffic carpet, lying under a table with our books— By the Great Horn Spoon!— windows bunker-narrow and long so the light had to angle down to us. Fifth grade, you’d say third, they would partner us up for reading ahead. For being hopelessly behind in the work we did when we felt like it. We were getting away with something. I remember after school, honey-butter bread, fried cheese in your mother’s skillet, cider hardening in the barn. Riding bikes around the schoolhouse your father fit with crown moulding one long summer, then cars. Ocean City, the AT, Maine. One of us followed the other to college. On my way to class I’d see you, no shirt and shoeless on the lawn, always high on something. I remember you singing Don’t sit under the apple tree with anyone else but me while you worked through my friends. I’m moving again. Your chicken-scratch notes line the books you lent me, gave maybe. Full of promise, promises 22 in rows across my desk. And behind breaking clouds climbs the slant of sun careful as any body through my window, unexpected but sure. 23 After Apple-Picking If it were five years ago I was dying, who would it have been who cared? That one boy I could count on to board the train Sundays I bought apples from my father at the market under the bridge. Or the surfer who got lost on the drive to the farm in the dark and didn’t want me after. Or the sculptor who made me something sadder than I knew. I have made mistakes. Thought it was going to rain just now, how the wind kicked up, the street trees losing their leaves over and over again. 24 Street Sweeping (for Bernard) Praise the parking policewoman ticketing the black Bronco of my friend, my neighbor who died at home last night. Praise she who takes down his plates, his model and make, and later (if you believe in anything), trust a higher-up shall know his name, and there will be a summons. 25 Counting Poem Perhaps you, too, loved a grandmother who didn’t like people. Who loved many dogs and one wounding parakeet, who kept a bird clock by the dinner table. It chirped and trilled rather than chimed each hour the sunlight spun feathers and dog hair into your cold-cut lunch. Into Coca-Cola that was mostly ice. The clock, good company for Ralph the bird, for ten of the fifty years she lived without my grandfather. She gave it to me after a doctor appraised her blockages at ninety, ninety-five, and two one-hundred-per-cents. Her heart opened anyway at eighty-three to try to save something we still wanted. The natural symbol is inadequate now: hiding down the hall from my children calling, my forehead chilled by a city window where a bird sings and sounds a lot like eleven o’clock. 26 Bananas for Stu A few weeks before your wife left, you went feral, showed up to the houses of friends around dinner time and I was out front pulling tearthumb to put in a banana tree I’d traded for with late-August peaches at the market, when I still worked markets, the year it kept hot through fall and peaches stayed dense and true. I was digging to shift the amended soil where it could do the most good, at the bottom, away from my bad mood garden: wolfsbane, belladonna, rue— I’d been alone so long, trading for plants all summer— when you stopped by to say bananas wouldn’t bear and would die in a DC minute of plunging cold, but that was the point while I tried what came my way without a care for winter. 27 Second Marriage Mortar joints are intended to be sacrificial, sensitive toward the needs of historic brick and stone. Slaked lime and local sand destroy a structure if overly strong. Analysis requires interpretation. Repointing restores physical and visual integrity, or detracts and damages the masonry: Mortar as bedding rather than glue, pigmented by lampblack, brickdust, oystershells, coral sands and locks of hair. The joint is tooled when thumbprint hard to match existing bonds. New construction bloom fades through normal weathering. River-rounded sand, free from impurities, a handful is part void between the grains. Good mortar fills each emptiness. And vines weigh down one corner of the building, vines planted by another. I say they’ll drag the whole wall down. You swear they hold it up. 28 Who do you wish was with us? I’ve traveled a week without this Welsh rain. The sky’s held off for a moment unweighted by an umbrella. Remembering can inoculate the clouds a little while. The difference between a walk in the rain and getting caught in the rain is not the rain. A walled garden’s pressed name- plates in Latin remind me I’ll never learn. On the eighth day, rain drives me under the arches of an old Swansea tree whose name I don’t know. Magpies want the high, dry ground and a wood pigeon sinks its grip in my hair. I swat at startled feathers. The bird settles near, cautious, but stays out of the weather. 29 Tumbling Run We’d overstayed the weather in the woods, a storm we knew was coming though we drove to Michaux without food or packs— the Civic’s glove compartment full of drugs— I’ve never been up for the mission except as chaperone. Shrooms I can’t eat because of stuff I know they grow in get the guys high while we hike the lower falls. Snow doubles and I wonder about coming down. It’s getting dark or I’m dying, Wagner says. George and O won’t talk at all. My brother’s prints loop off behind us: boulders big as houses, sloped roofs, no doors, holding left foot right and I see him crumpled below in each gully. Catch my breath and follow his billy-goat scramble down and back up in the slow going of the not-brave, of the congenitally sober. Alone. Call his name, dulled half-dark by anger, burned down to blue warmth of worry. I’d always hounded his adventures and brought him back when I thought he’d needed it. When he does answer, he’s so close I reach out in moonlight held aloft by a veil of pines and touch his outstretched hand. Because he’d become a tree in a field full of trees and tried to do what the rest were doing; as I try to make sense of what sisters are supposed to do, no one to look up to, no one looking up to me later, years after the long childhood spent rehearsing losses. 30 Kevlar and Calfskin The first time I see a rock maple drum shell without its hardware and heads, I think I'm looking at a tree ring. I think I'm looking at a year lifted from a nest of years, one self-contained circle, a record of the wet and dry seasons. I reason the tree’s other rings have become other drums. A trap set of years surrounds my father while he and I figure what’s wrong with his snare. Eight gut-strings wound with wire rest in his lap like links of chain mail. He dismantles an instrument with the confidence of a man who builds things, who trusts his tools, who never loses any pieces and will re-make them whole. I get to listen to his busy-work banter if I clean lug nuts and tension rods. He says about drums, there's Kevlar and calfskin, not much in between. Dad relies on bulletproof durability. Tough new drumheads sink black holes into the carpet. Part of me might disappear inside should I reach for them. Without its skins, the drum's silence is a kind of nakedness. Parallel grain runs the wood like ledger lines in a composition book— like lines and spaces without their music on. I record everything my father says when we work like this. Two drumheads, get it? Not much in between. It’s years before we all leave him. It’s years before I learn drums aren't tree rings, before I see one made from a plank ripped from its tree, unstraightened by steam and steel, and sanded into a perfect circle meant to amplify. I can’t yet differentiate shaping from warping. I laugh like Kevlar and calfskin and emptiness are all things I’ve long known. I laugh like I know my father well. I’ve blown back the tiny feelers in my ears to be close to him. Asleep on the quilt that muffles his kick drum, I think this is love, my heart bucking and stumbling to match step with the mallet striking, finding its own music. 31 Crayfish Because water caught the light like flesh on the lid of a tin can, Conewago Creek rose in narrow locks and pooled the sunset. I climbed after it to the ridge where a spring the size of a child’s bath began from nothing. Water occurred to a stack of rocks until the damp spilled under leaves, unnoticed, along the same logging road I wandered each day of my childhood that I’d care to remember. I saw a beauty I wanted to enlarge and did the wrong thing: I returned with a shovel. You have to understand, above the woods, where the orchard clung to its cleared south-eastern slope, fruit trees were dying in their rows. My mother had paid a water witch from town to site a new well. The dowser, wife of the well-digger, walked with a peach branch balanced in her palms all morning, and divined what would be a poor spot for her husband to dig. Not telling about the spring made it mine to ruin with improvements. I numbed my hands for days piling rocks and emptying the bowl of old leaves and silt. Things that had lived there dried on the bank. The spring bled mud to heal its waters of my digging. I sliced a crayfish in half before I stopped. I’d heard they could trace freshwater to its start. It died among the rounded stones with its face turned toward the source. 32 Against Elegy You learned this somewhere, the five mirrors of loss. It’s not what I want for my children. I’m going now. I don’t wish to be followed. Give me all I have before I’m gone and I’ll divvy it up with you. Grant me buttermilk in a cup of the living world. Allow me bread that’s risen a few times, and slowly. Where I’ve been with you less in twos and threes than lonely, be alone at my end’s unbuilding. 33 Pruning You have to open up the tree to the idea of bearing, center out, sun to the lower branches. Slice at suckers until your forearms ache. The adventitious limbs are whip-thin and incapable of peaches. Cull them before the sap swells everything green and pink. Any child knows what to keep and where to cut the upstarts. Underfoot, they bloom for days behind you, unchosen among the roots where they lay their petals down. 34 Hillwater I. I’d step off the bus and want the words out of any music. I liked the wind’s rush down the orchard’s slope, the cattle gate swung wide to the woods and my ears ringing. My skin dulled the day’s high blush. Everything slowed and opened. I went first by my eyes, mindful for rattlers, second by my hearing for the same. An insect hum from school could linger like a colony for hours in the brain. Once the forest floor started speaking like a small far-off fire. I moved a broad-leaf brown’s worth of blanket to find the shape of a fawn in beetlebacks that curved their eyelights up at me. My whole life, I had the good sense to keep looking for the things I found. A hide beetle is named for what it cleans and keeps whole, the kind kept to expose museum bones and get the middle gone. I walked the fawn’s flat length in the woods before learning the rustling meant a river of nothing underfoot. Above, the devil in its acre: brambles I remember best for failing to thrive. Every farm has one, untenable rock tripping up the silted hill, sogged or cracked dry, wind-fallowed. Some plants like to suffer, and you should put them there. And my mother, sister, and I, our habit of debt-hungry men in their vineyards wild and tame, eating grapes to give up the wine harvest after middling harvest. Autumn sons and vernal daughters; careless fun, then broken waters. Remember burning the mortgage by the barn door? 35 Cars in the cornfield, campfires, dances all night on fallen arches. The exhaust of red trucks running still sends summer’s lemon-sugar hands to me. How my first love heaved his heartbroad chest under his apron when I was showy with a second child. Pressing two sides of a tablecloth with the tops of our thighs, all our decisions neat between us. His wife a lot like me, heavy where I used to be. It can take twenty years to know a thing you’re told. Over and over I returned to the trees I understood, retying timber boundaries’ blue flags that girded those I held and looked up to. Old-growth gone anyway, toppled and torn across re-sheared logging roads, pungent stumps left to read and count out my birth in concentric rings. There is a name for the creek made from a spring that tumbles next to its empty bed. You’ll hear it if you go alone, or with one willing to say nothing a while: Conewago, Conewago, hillwater swept to falls in Lenape. II. Catholics crossed the valley here in wagons to build their brick box, hang thick glass wed by lead. Valley of The White Squaw is named for Mary Jemison, whose family was scalped, whose cornsilk hair saved her from having that part taken. Beauty can protect like that if one wants it to live and is better armed than another. They lined us up in elementary school with our backs against the board, then culled the dark and short-haired. Leaving bucktoothed Tina and bucktoothed me... This tittering spool of yellow -bellied cruelties I could have stopped if I’d better known the ugly curled inside. Always listening for danger, waiting each footfall out on leaf-deep hills 36 in case anything poisonous cared to lead. New-spawned copperheads the worst for their unregulated woundings. I heard a rattlesnake just once, one boot raised from the dry creek’s wiregrass, but the sound shook the knuckled oaks and swaying pines. I sweat out the bone-knocked voice, thrown and echoed back. Next steps are often treacherous. The woodsman’s son crosses the road at twelve to quit clearing our apple brush. He’s felled a tree on his father. I’ll fall for all four brothers of the Mennonites with the accurate family name of Baum. Back then, you’d notice my father’s Reid-red hair, our highland shyness, my mother’s Argento silver threading her foothill braids. We are not far from the naming of this place. Bears come for our grapes from Bear Mountain. Narrows Road is so. The waterwheel along Mill Run has nowhere else to go. Any path leads to my grandmother alone and sunk in her lumpy blue chair. Oxygen flows audible through the house from silver tanks to greening tubes meeting under her nose. I’d kneel on the carpet to interrupt the TV so she’d say something sweet: I see you have the troubles with your hair or I spent today with your pictures and threw out the worst. Stacks of things between us we don’t understand, her wedding book on top. We don’t discuss my grandfather gone to his girlfriend’s condo for the weekend. What do you call a woman led on fifty years alongside a man and wife? A town beauty is stuck hillside. Her granddaughters lack town or trousseau, though my sister kisses the four boys next door and finds winter trips for her life to grow. Grandmother laughs at her black thumb in the garden. She praises my sister’s hands, elegant and poised above keys or strings. 37 My sister takes music wherever she goes. III. Our family ends before we each start our own. Our brother returns from college to hear how to run the land, money like water pulled up and put down by the roots. More than we could tend, always more to grit and pretend. Our mother counts out crackers at the table, busy being thin. She takes lovers my brother’s age by spring, when long mounds of berries need gathered and sold. My father walks the fence-line all morning. With three shells in his left breast pocket, he finds nothing in the woods, then his wife and a worker in the barn— If you do not make your life, you’ll be given the one you have over and over. Suppose you were raised by a lady who fell in love with everyone. You’d be cruel too, taught to hunt by your father’s wanders, the first time a truck hit its brakes in the street so a man could have to tell you, you’re something perfect. Imagine trying to stop what you were, deep outside looks you couldn’t control. My mother’s beauty was a craziness she had so long she gifted it to strangers. Time has given it a name. Some questions beg for an answer, some answers beg for the same. I lost the fed-beetle fawn when I searched again. I thought there’d be bones, or winged generations of the scavengers I’d heard. I’ve never so faithfully tracked back my travel. Such a small death; I think I meant to bring a piece home. Instead, all around, a shock of white I’d waited my life to see: the fluted necks of Indian Pipe, sun-shunning flowers peeking 38 from the ground, curled like lampposts, greenless ghosts nearly glowing. There is one place I will ever know and I’ve seen it for the last time, covered in plants that sow themselves to the highfield channery loam. There is a field full of tiny bells that stays silent over the dead. Ghost flowers reach for their living from the tangled roots of others. I almost wish I could have shown you and the children I would’ve liked to dip in the creek’s deep spring. May there be logic to such blooming. I stood a long time before knowing to leave them there. 39 Tending Better to be buried in the season of your own yard’s flowers. Though most of us, yourself included, go in the month of unsold roses. Better to be finite in your longing. I wasn’t one you woke for at the end. This is handholding work. Sitting on a carpet that smells like everything you tried to get out of it. There’s a message I can’t erase: My sister says, quick now. They put you in a room with the blinds down. I’ll do the viewing but do not attend the dying. Why take my body from yours while yours lived tethered to the breathing machines? On the other side of a wall that used to be a door, I hold up this book with my name on it. Best to be remembered by the church-yard’s light across the valley, one that comes on at dusk like a bird I’ve seen all my life and not heard. 40